Add All to Shopping List
Add to Meal Planner
|Calories270Calories from Fat140|
|% DAILY VALUE|
|Calories from Fat140|
|% DAILY VALUE|
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet. Your Daily Values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs.
DC Lopez 19 hours ago
Yes this is the best potato salad ever. No need to look for any other recipe!
Carissa a day ago
Best potato salad ever! I add dill and oh it’s soo good!
Patricia Mallory 15 days ago
very good. will make it again!
Amy Kins 22 days ago
I am not a potato salad fan but I liked this recipe.
Bec a month ago
I thought I made enough for two nights, but my son got hungry in the late evening and ate enough for four!
Paris Gonzalez a month ago
This potato salad was good but my stepdad’s is even better
James Reynolds 3 months ago
Great it was a big hit
Brittany Guzman 3 months ago
We did not enjoy this. It would be good with a little extra mustard, extra salt and no onions. Add some pickles... The potatoes need to be cooked a little longer. Honestly, we just didn’t like this recipe but it has hope.
Sandness 4 months ago
Very good! It was easy to make and came together quickly. Husband loved it.
Watie B. 4 months ago
All my guests love it so much & cant stop eating it. I sprinkle it with vegan bacon bits & it taste marv!
Kathleen Magana 5 months ago
Excellent! It was as close to my mom’s potato salad as I could get 💕
IncredibleHomeCook 6 months ago
Turned out great!! My family loved it
Connie Penton 7 months ago
Wonderful! The name says it... it is the best potato salad. Everyone loved it!
Amie Hernandez 7 months ago
amazing floavor i only left out the celery and onions because i dont like crunch texture.
Sal 7 months ago
Great recipe made it 3 times everyone loved it
Suzy W. 8 months ago
very yummy my best salad yet !!! im happy
Casey Wertepny 8 months ago
i used spicy dijon mustard instead for extra flavor
Van Mersbergen 8 months ago
Due to an allergy, I substituted pickles in place of celery. I also decided to use pickle juice instead of white vinegar. The recipe was delicious, and I'm sure would be just as great made as-is.
Brandon Bishop 9 months ago
This did not turn out well. Flavor was definitely lacking. With so many potato salad recipes around this one is not worth a try.
3Syllables 9 months ago
Delicious and super easy! We didn’t have any celery seed but it was delicious without it
Patricia B. 9 months ago
Just Awesome. I've made my moms German Potato salad many times but this just melts in your mouth.
Caroline B. 10 months ago
Flavors are VERY good. Too much mayo for my taste had to add in some more potatoes. Next time I make it I will only use 1 c Mayo
Michelle H. a year ago
The BEST traditional potatoe salad that I have ever made. Everyone loved it. I will be making this one over and over.
Don 2 years ago
Super creamy and tangy. Easy to make. This is the only potato salad I will make from now on.
Cathy 2 years ago
Classic Will make again and again