40 Reasons Why We Love Christmas Cookies
There are thousands of cookie recipes out there. But with so many options to choose from, where do you start? To make your life a bit easier, we've compiled this delicious collection of 40 fabulous holiday cookie favorites.
While there are a lot of things about the holiday season that make me happy, cookies are definitely toward the top of the list. Forget about sugar plums — the visions that dance in MY head are of shortbread and molasses chews; biscotti and pecan tassies; French tuiles and Austrian linzer cookies; palmiers and peanut butter blossoms. The sheer number of cookies that you can make is enough to inspire child-like wonder in the most seasoned baker. After days of dreaming about sweets, I'm happy to share this list of 40 favorites with you.
Before diving into the recipes, let's stop to consider why you ought to be making a beeline for your mixer this December (just in case you still need convincing). Think hard about the humble cookie and all the redeeming qualities of this annual baking tradition. Here's the love letter my inner child came up with:
The Reasons That Christmas Cookies Are The Best
- They’re inexpensive.
- They’re easy to make.
- They make great handmade gifts (and are perfect for that co-worker you have no idea what to buy for).
- There’s an astounding variety to please every taste.
- Bite size = built-in portion control.
- Dough can be made in advance and frozen.
- Fun project to make with kids.
- Cookie exchanges are a great excuse for an early holiday party.
- They taste great — and make your kitchen smell fantastic.
- Sharing traditional cookie plates allows us to practice generosity (and reminds us of generations past).
- Get to play with cookie cutters while blasting Christmas music.
- Santa needs a midnight snack.
So Many Cookies!
With so many different types of cookies to choose from (and all the variations of each), it can be hard to narrow down your baking list to a reasonable number of recipes. Like a good cheese board, the key to the perfect cookie plate lies in variety and contrast. When picking cookie recipes, think about mixing up colors, textures, shapes, and flavors. A collection with something for everyone might include:
- Something chocolate (and something not)
- Something spiced — cinnamon, ginger, or nutmeg are all great
- Something with nuts (and something without)
- Something crunchy, like biscotti, lace cookies, or bark
- Something non-traditional, like a bar, truffle, or fudge
The easiest way to get variety, of course, is to arrange a good old-fashioned cookie swap. Have 11 guests join you, and have each person bring a double batch of a different kind of cookie to trade. After a bit of sampling (and perhaps a glass of wine or two), everyone puts together a take-home container with 12 types of cookies. Even better, have a baking party where you can get an assembly line going and bake all your favorites with friends and family.
Tools Of The Trade
What’s nice about baking cookies is that you really don’t need much in the way of equipment — a pan, an oven, and a watch are all you truly need. But if you’re planning on baking in bulk, here are some things that will make your life easier:
Stand mixer: This one is a game changer for cookies. If you’re used to using a hand mixer (or brute strength), you won’t believe how much easier it is to pull together cookie dough with a stand mixer. You’ll be wanting to make batch after batch! Which brings us to…
An extra bowl: Having a spare stand mixer bowl allows you to get started on the dough for a different kind of cookie while you’re still scooping out the cookie dough from the previous batch. It’s also key if you’re doing layered bars that require more than one type of dough.
Lots of baking sheets: I recommend having four sheets, although you certainly can get by with fewer. It’s nice to have at least two so you can be putting more dough on one sheet while your first sheet is in the oven. Four allows you to either bake two sheets at a time or rotate through the sheets so that you’re not putting your dough on a piping hot pan.
Parchment paper or silicone baking mat: Both of these will help ensure your cookies don’t stick to your baking sheet; the silicone baking mat is also particularly good at making sure the bottoms of your cookies don’t burn.
Cookie scoop: While this gadget falls clearly in the “not necessary” category, it is a helpful tool if you’re doing a lot of drop cookies. These small ice-cream-scoop-like devices help you make cookies that are all the same size, so they’ll bake evenly.
40 Best Christmas Cookie Recipes
The best reason of all to bake cookies this Christmas? The perfect cookie recipe! Take a look through our mouth-watering collection of the best Christmas cookie recipes for 40 reasons why YOU should get your oven started.
Classic Spritz Cookies
These traditional German butter cookies herald the beginning of cookie season.
Chai Spiced Sugar Cookies
The taste of chai is perfect for this time of year; why not spice up your standard sugar cookie recipe?
These cookie cups from the American south bring a taste of pie to your cookie buffet.
No Bake Holiday Oreo Truffles
The oreo truffle is an easy recipe that never fails to wow your guests.
Italian Anisette Cookies
These Italian beauties are incredibly versatile — feel free to omit the anise altogether, or replace with an extract of your choice, such as almond or lemon.
Mint Mocha Cookie Sandwiches
With a good dose of espresso and dark chocolate, these chewy treats deliver a kick you're sure to enjoy.
Maraschino Cherry Shortbread Cookies
These shortbread cookies are rich with butter, of course, but melt in your mouth because of the powdered sugar. And what isn't better with a cherry on top?
A simple mixture of vanilla, sugar, and egg whites helps these trees win the award for "cutest cookie recipe of the season."
Mint Chocolate Macaron
The popularity of macarons isn't all about good looks — the delicate cookie texture and sweet filling make them a delight to eat as well!
Cranberry Almond Biscotti
Biscotti provide a welcome contrast to the abundance of sugary, gooey treats that are everywhere this time of year. Biscotti also keep longer than regular cookies, making them a favorite holiday gift.
Gluten-Free Russian Tea Cookies
The Russian tea cake (also known as a Mexican wedding cookie) is a classic addition to any Christmas cookie spread, and guarantees a white Christmas wherever you go!
Chewy Molasses Cookies
With a crackly top and a dusting of shiny sugar, these old-fashioned drop cookies please young and old alike.
A special waffle iron is needed to make the beautiful designs on the traditional Italian pizzelle. If you're not a fan of anise, feel free to substitute orange extract. Pro tip: these make excellent sandwich treats when filled with fig jam!
Toffee Pecan Cookies
Is there anything more Christmassy than toffee and nuts? A sprinkling of sea salt over the top makes these cookies simultaneously homey and gourmet.
Peppermint Chocolate Cookies
Dark chocolate and white chocolate — together at last! With these peppermint chocolate cookies, there's no need to pick a favorite.
Spiced Eggnog Snowball Cookies
The spices in these festive hand-rolled cookies bring the taste of eggnog to one perfect little bite. But if that wasn't enough, yes, there's some actual eggnog in the dough, too.
Mexican Cinnamon Cookies
This Mexican spin on a snickerdoodle is a great way to bring the flavors of cinnamon and sugar to your cookie tray.
Chocolate Crackle Cookies
These rich and fudgy rounds are a true chocolate lover's delight. Take my word on this one; I should know.
Walnut Meyer Lemon Shortbread Cookies
December is Meyer lemon season in the southern states. These buttery shortbreads are a great way to highlight the floral citrus flavor of this coveted seasonal fruit.
Biscoff Explosion Cookies
Sometimes known as "St. Nicholas Day Cookies," Speculoos cookies were traditionally served on St. Nicholas Day in Belgium, France, and the Netherlands. Popularized by an airline and the invention of "cookie butter," speculoos has taken the U.S. by storm in recent years. These "explosion" cookies are a decidedly decadent take on the spiced cookie of the old world.
Star of Bethlehem Cookies
Stars of Bethlehem, Peanut Blossoms, Peanut Butter Kiss Cookies ... whatever you call them, these classics keep coming back year after year. And with good reason! These cookies satisfy all the peanut butter lovers in your life while adding visual drama to your cookie plate.
S’Mores Kiss Cookies
This playful twist on blossom cookies sees a chocolate kiss resting atop a marshmallow snowdrift. Instead of peanut butter, these cookies have graham cracker crumbs inside. Finally, a nut-free blossom that can be enjoyed by people with peanut allergies!
Orange Blossom Sablé Cookies
Sablé means “sandy” in French, and refers to the crumbly texture of these shortbread-like cookies. Full of almonds and orange zest, these sablés have a bright and buttery flavor that melt in your mouth along with the chocolate coating.
Full of seasonal spices, citrus, and persimmons, these cookies just scream "December."
Despite their ornate appearance, palmiers are easy to make and add visual and textural variety to your holiday table. Feel free to experiment with different fillings: fruit jams, nuts, and chocolate are all good choices.
The unique and satisfyingly chewy texture of these traditionally gluten-free Sicilian bites comes from the combination of almond meal and egg whites.
Chocolate Chip Cookies
No, chocolate chip cookies aren't specifically for the holidays, but as America's favorite cookie, they shouldn't be left off the list! These jumbo bakery-style cookies make a lovely gift that everyone will enjoy.
Coffee Blond Brownies
Let's be straight here: brownies are not cookies. But they DO have a place on your holiday table, particularly when bringing flavors like coffee, pecan, and chocolate to the mix. With piles of cookies everywhere, a brownie can be a nice alternative treat. Looking for more brownie ideas? Check out these 10 Must Bake Brownies.
Almond Lace Cookies
Lace cookies are another way to add some beauty to your cookie plate. These delicate disks provide a bit of crunch, a bit of chew, and a lot of satisfaction.
Walnut Mushroom Cookies
These mini mushrooms give the meringue tree cookies a run for their money in the "cutest cookie" category. Why not make both (along with a yule log) for a forest-themed celebration?
I had to include this recipe, as I've been making it every Christmas since the recipe was first published in 2013. These cookies are extra chocolately and buttery, yet not too sweet. Flakes of Maldon sea salt on top provide the perfect salty-sweet-chocolate bite.
While also not technically a cookie, truffles are another nice counterpoint to the standard cookie bonanza. And what could be more festive than champagne? With white chocolate and orange, this celebratory bite will turn heads.
Peppermint Crunch Sugar Cookies
Unlike a rolled sugar cookie, these drop cookies are effortless to make. Adorned with candy cane pieces, they've got just as much Christmas spirit as their cookie cutter cousins.
Peppermint Swirl Sugar Cookies
In this take on the sugar cookie, we're bringing festive colors into the mix! Make a batch of green and a batch of red to really wake up your spread.
Glittering Lemon Cookie Sandwiches
These pretty lemon sandwiches look like bells ... or are they Christmas lights? Their bold color and shape make them perfect for packaging up in little boxes and giving away as gifts.
Christmas Tree Sugar Cookies
THE Christmas cookie classic, sugar cookies with royal icing are perfect for an afternoon baking project with kids.
Salted Caramel-Stuffed Chocolate Truffle Cookies
Caramel. Chocolate. Truffle. Need we say more?
Chocolate Caramel Pecan Thumbprint Cookies
Use your thumb to make a divit in the dough and fill it with gooey caramel to make these decadent holiday bites.
Classic Gingerbread Cookie
Whether you're making classic gingerbread men or gingerbread sweaters, this classic cookie recipe has got your back.
Bark is a welcome break from traditional cookies. This unusual recipe is not your typical holiday bark, however — it's got a shortbread cookie base that's topped with bark. Everyone will want to snap off a piece of this holiday treat!